Wednesday, January 30, 2008

Tajikistan is almost in WTO

Tajik officials and the working party, established by the WTO General Council on 18 July 2001, gave very optimistic statements regarding the accession of Tajikistan to WTO. Tajikistan submitted the membership application to WTO in May, 2001 and since then many meetings were held and millions were spent to make all necessary arrangements for smooth accession to WTO.

From January 21 to 25 of current year a WTO delegation paid (rus) a visit to Tajikistan to discuss the remaining issues. Mr. Clyde Kull, the head of the working party, pointed out that they together with Tajik G-men worked out a proper and transparent legislation that meets WTO requirements. Personally I often hear people say that our legislation de jure is one of the best in CIS but de facto is not always enforced as desired.

The members of the working party are quite significant countries such as USA, Canada, EU countries, Japan, Australia and China which are interested in conducting trade with Tajikistan. Very promising. So what are the advantages of being WTO member for Tajikistan? Membership will provide Tajikistan an opportunity to defend its interests along with other members on equal terms through discussions and negotiations on the collective basis. They say that flow of foreign goods into Tajikistan will have a good impact on Tajik private sector promoting fair competition and providing people with wide range of products. In this case, the demerit is that unprotected branches (for instance, field of services) of national economy will mostly lose their positions on the market and thus, most probably, face serious difficulties. Taking into account the fact that most of the fields could be referred as unprotected and unstable, I may assume that membership will give our economy hard time.

According to well-known Tajik economist Hojimahmad Umarov, Tajikistan will only win from membership. He believes that membership will improve the image of Tajikistan for foreign investors and make Tajikistan look more trustworthy. Nevertheless, in my opinion we have to consider all the side effects and thoroughly scrutinize the case of Kyrgyzstan, China, Viet Nam, Armenia, etc. to be able to tackle all the challenges that will certainly emerge once we become a member of WTO. It is hard to predict when exactly Tajikistan will be ready for accession but the process has started long ago and sooner or later Tajikistan will definitely become a member of WTO and join the rest of the crew.

Source: New Eurasia - Tajikistan

Central Asia in WTO:
Kazakhstan - observer
Kyrgyzstan - 20 December 1998
Tajikistan - observer
Turkmenistan - not present
Uzbekistan - observer

[Webstan]

Sunday, January 20, 2008

New "Internet in Central Asia" iGoogle Gadget

Now you can read the latest news and reports about Internet in Central Asia including topics about the Internet in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan on your personal Google homepage: www.igoogle.com or www.google.com/ig.

To read the latest blog posts please add our Webstan blog iGoogle gadget, just click this button: Add to Google

Thank you very much and hope you will like it!

Economic Freedom 2008 - Kyrgyzstan is in Top 70


The 14th annual Index of Economic Freedom prepared by the Heritage Foundation and the Wall Street Journal was publicized on the 14th January. 162 countries took part and the economic freedom of each country was measured by 10 indicators such as free trade, business and investment opportunity, and private property.

Kyrgyzstan was the 70th in the list. It was ahead of its neighbors Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan. It showed even better results than Poland and Turkey. All countries and their ratings were shown on one map and one can see that Kyrgyzstan has taken place somewhere in the middle.

So, according to the Heritage Foundation, Kyrgyzstan’s freedom equals to 61,1%. Here is the percentage for each indicator: Business opportunity - 60.4%, Free trade - 81.4% , Fiscal freedom - 93.9%, Freedom from state- 76.1%, Monetary freedom- 75.6%, Investment freedom- 50%, Financial freedom - 50%, Private ownership - 30%.

This way Kyrgyzstan is in the top 70 of the most economically free countries. It did much better than last year and according to the researchers it is due to the improved investment climate of the country. Kyrgyzstan now is the 12th country member of 30 countries of Asia region and its scores are more than average.

Source: New Eurasia (Russian version) (English version)
Original report source: Heritage Foundation

Ratings:
1. Hong Kong
2. Singapore
3. Ireland
4. Australia
5. United States
6. New Zealand
7. Canada
8. Chile
9. Switzerland
10. United Kingdom
..................
70. Kyrgyzstan (Kyrgyz Republic)
..................
74. Turkey
75. Slovenia
76. Kazakhstan
..................
80. Greece
..................
83. Poland
..................
114. Tajikistan
..................
130. Uzbekistan
..................
152. Turkmenistan
..................

Full list: Index of Economic Freedom

Kyrgyzstan Profile: Economic Freedom 2008 - Kyrgyz Republic

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Cybercrimes and Cyberterrorism Threat in Kazakhstan

Source: Computer Crime Research Center

Introduction

As with many other new technologies in the past, the World Wide Web presents us with great opportunities for progress as well as potential for misuse. Here are only a few of the ones committed on the Internet: network attacks, credit card fraud, stealing money from bank accounts, corporate espionage, child pornography distribution. These crimes represent a significant social danger to Ukraine and other CIS Confederation of Independent States countries. Below I discuss three different countries and the ways in which they have managed their technology infrastructure and dealt with Internet crime.

1. The Republic of Moldova
In Moldova, the number of Internet users grows each day. Out of a total of 100,000 Internet users 20,000 are government officials.

In 2006-2007 all attempted computer attacks and infringement of information systems were successfully neutralized and did not cause any significant problems with normal operation of state information systems and web sites.

Maintaining the security of the telecommunication system, entails a number of technical measures and methods. These methods are employed by the Center of Special Telecommunications.
One of the main factors of reliable, stable and safe functioning of the state information structure is having a special, modern and protected environment. In 2005, the Center of Special Telecommunications began to develop a modern and protected telecommunication system for their government agencies. Today this system has more than 30km of information fiber-optic network systems that link more than 60 state agencies, including the Office of the President, the Parliament, the Ministries of Commerce and Economy, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Ministry of Defense, the General Prosecutor’s Office, the Information and Security Service, Border and Customs Offices, the Center for Fighting Economic Crimes and Corruption and other state offices. State agencies can already exchange information through high-speed, wide-band, encrypted channels.

The central information center of the telecommunication system of state agencies was upgraded. State agencies can use special services like high-speed and protected access to the Internet, protected data exchange, and e-mail services. There is a technical support office for all information services provided in all state agencies.
One of the top-priority tasks at present is to develop protected communication systems between state offices in the capital and regional state offices. Taking into account the proliferation of computer criminals, the Center of Special Telecommunications is focused on implementing high-tech solutions in the sphere of information security, including technologies of digital signatures.

The digital signature is one of the significant means to provide high level protection of e-documents. Introduction of digital signatures in the republic increased the use of e-documents in the communications of state authorities and public offices; this creates a fair basis for implementing the electronic exchange of documents, and increases the efficiency of document flow and administrative work.

In fact, only 12% of computer crimes in Moldova become the subject of the criminal prosecution. Georgiy Suprunov, sales director of the largest telecommunications company in Moldova, said at the international seminar “Control of Internet Use” held in Chisinau that computer crime is unfavourable for companies because computer crimes decrease their business rating.

2. Republic of Kazakhstan
Representatives of Kazakhstan, at a Euro-Asian forum on information security, stated that about 500,000 hacker attacks each month are attempted on their state information networks. Hackers regularly try to break into the databases of banks and companies to try to steal large sums of money and to try to obtain confidential information. The struggle against cyber crime is hampered because the government and these companies do not want to reveal information on these attacks. In addition, most hackers attack from abroad.

The global use of modern information technologies, by governments and financial institutions all over the world, makes the solution of information security problems a top priority. Besides the direct harm from possible intrusion into systems, information gained through cyber crime may become a serious means to human oppression. For this reason Kazakhstan, adopted state programs to maintain information security, maintain state secrets and other necessary means including the highest level of cooperation with the Committee of National Security.

It is important to note the need to balance maximum openness of access to information, as mandated by the Constitution of Kazakhstan, with the needs of national security.
The sphere of information security also demands rational investment of state financial resources in building modern information system and maintenance of the system’s security.

Under the Protocol on Cooperation in the area of fighting computer crimes of CIS countries, a computer crime unit was created within the Committee of National Security. The unit’s primary tasks are to find and prevent crimes related to information resources of state authorities.

It is essential to cooperate with European and Western countries in this area. Authorized state agencies are interested in ratifying the EU Convention on Cyber Crime adopted in 2001. This will further cooperation in this area of fighting computer crime and to will enable colleagues from all over the world to share their experiences in this arena.

3. Republic of Byelorussia
As it is well-known, a favorable environment for any crimes in general, and computer crimes in particular, may be explained by the conjunction of three factors: motivation, opportunity and the absence of capable counteraction. When all three are present, , there is impunity for criminals and the opportunity for repeated illegal actions in the area of computer information. Byelorussian law enforcement first encountered cases of computer crime in 1998. Subsequently, law enforcement agencies began to fight cyber criminals using traditional legal rules. However this approach was unsuccessful, as most computer crimes grew out of traditional ones in new ways.

The New Criminal Code of the Republic of Byelorussia enacted from 2001 contains a number of articles permitting prosecution for crimes against property (article 212 of the CC) and information security (articles 349-355 of the CC), committed using computer technologies. Among newly introduced crimes are the following six: Article 349, Unauthorized access to computer information; Article 350, Modification of computer information; Article 351, Computer sabotage; Article 352, Unauthorized capture of computer information; Article 353, Production or marketing of special means designed to obtain unauthorized access to computer systems or networks; Article 354, Development, use or spread of detrimental computer programs; Article 355, Violation of computer system or network operating rules.

Taking into account the reality of the potential threat of the misuse of information technologies, the Ministry of Internal Affairs gradually realized that a complex program of counteraction to these crimes was needed; this program was created in 2001. Special units were created in the ministry specifically to fight high-tech crimes. Today cyber crime problems are solved by the high-tech crime unit at the ministry and its regional departments.

The state program for implementing information technology infrastructure of the Republic of Belarus for 2003-2005, (forecasted to 2010), "Electronic Belarus" was developed to carry out the instructions of the President of Belarus from May 27, 2002, № 09/540-20 by a group of specialists from different organizations and organizations of the republic. This endeavour is under the control of the National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Belarus and is mandated to remove registered negative moments and factors. The program has inter-agency collaboration and is based on the basic regulations of the state policy in the area of information technology.

According to Vladislav Kaluqa, the Chief Executive of "Beltelekom" the number of Internet users in Byelorussia is over 2 million. According to statistical information from 2003, the number of Internet users in the country was more than 1 million. Every day thousands of Byelorussians connect to global networks .

Between 1998 and 2001 most cyber crimes were related to stealing goods in e-markets using stolen credit cards, these crimes were committed by single criminals. Now, crimes are more often related to hacking with the goal of stealing information; hacker attacks on the web resources of schools, universities, ISPs, mass media, companies and citizens, in order to obtain restricted information or to disrupt an organization’s normal operation.

Almost everywhere, repeated crimes committed with the use of computers and stolen credit card information, unauthorized access to computer information, alteration of computer information, computer sabotage, and the distribution of slander on public persons and officials, occurs on the Internet. Criminals actively use technologies to gain maximum profit from illegal financial operations.

An increase in Internet use and higher levels of education contributed to a rise in cyber crime in Belarus last year. Belarusian computer criminals caused about $400,000 in damages to computer criminals caused about $400,000 in damages to foreign institutions last year, mostly banks, cyber crime investigators reported. Hackers targeted only a few domestic banks. The country's High Technology Crimes Investigation Department started 429 legal proceedings against hackers and the FBI (U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigations) visited the country twice to get information for its own investigations. As the number of Belarusians attending university rises, so does the number of cyber criminals. Officials at the Ministry of Internal Affairs estimate 80% of the 189 hackers known in the country are students. In 2006 almost 2000 crimes involving computers, software and the Internet occurred in the country and 175 criminal cases were prosecuted involving illegal actions in the area of information security; in 2005 the number of cases prosecuted was 178.

In August, last year, the Belarusian Internet community was stressed by a number of hacker attacks. Anonymous hackers altered hundreds of Belarusian web sites. The analysis of crimes committed in the “digital” sphere shows that the majority (55%) of illegal actions were related to computer crimes: criminal infringements in the sphere of computer information and thefts using computers.
Most computer crimes in Belarus are committed by persons aged 18-29 years, (60,7%), while 30 years and older represents about one third, (33,3%). Under-aged persons make up 6%. Viewed from another perspective: 11,9% were committed by students, 21,4% by unemployed individuals, 9,5% by women and 3,6% by prisoners (with some overlap among these classes).

According to the Belarusian Ministry of Internal Affairs’ Public Relations Department, illegal access to computer information, illegal modification of computer information, computer sabotage and credit card theft and fraud are the most typical computer crimes in Belarus. In 2005 cooperation of Russian and Belarusian Ministries of Internal Affairs resulted in the uncovering of an international criminal network specializing in computer crimes. In June of 2005 Belarusian police uncovered an international criminal group that stole USD 112,000 from Citibank USA’s clients’ accounts during August through November 2003. In 2003, a criminal group specializing in the online dissemination of child pornography was uncovered in Minsk. The total profit of that group totalled USD 3 million. Currently, the Belarusian Ministry of Internal Affairs participates in the international special operation Innocent Images Task Force. A Ministry of Internal Affairs spokesman stressed that 60% of computer crimes are committed by people from 18 to 29 years old, and 8% committed by juvenile delinquents.

According to the official data of the Interior Ministry of the Republic of Belarus, trends of computer crimes in Belarus are significant. High-tech crimes in 2002 showed a 80,5% growth as compared to 2001, 924 such crimes occurred in 2002 and 512 crimes occurred in 2001.
The experience of counteracting computer crime in Belarus has raised a number of grave questions related to the investigation of computer crimes and the cooperation of law enforcement agencies of different countries. The high-tech crimes unit at the Interior Ministry of the Republic of Belarus, together with the National High Tech Crimes Unit of Great Britain held a joint operation “Fire wall” in 2004. The operation resulted in finding and arresting international criminal group members. These criminals produced, sold and used forged credit cards. The Interior Ministry of the Republic of Belarus emphasized the significance of combating computer crimes. There was a meeting at the Ministry dedicated to these issues in 2004. Counteracting cyber crime was flagged as a high priority issue, a program of actions including cooperation of all agencies was adopted.

4. Conclusion
The agreement on cooperation of CIS countries in fighting cyber crimes, adopted six years ago in Minsk, laid the basis for the strategy and tactics of law enforcement for these countries. This agreement also put in place a mechanism for cooperation to combat high tech crimes. However, these countries didn’t fulfill their obligations related to joint investigation measures and the creation of special information systems and cooperation in the field of training skilled police officers.

CIS countries are at a complicated and critical stage in solving those numerous problems related to the investigation of cyber crimes. Massive Distributed Denial of Service (DDOS) attacks, where hundreds of compromised BOTNET computers, and even networks from several countries, are used to attack web sites in other countries; computer worms causing damage to two-thirds of the countries of the world raise for us the fundamental questions related to localization and jurisdiction of these crimes and criminals.

Recently, a number of measures were taken in order to develop efficient methods of international collaboration in combating cyber crime at regional and international levels. These methods produced significant results. Cooperation is necessary in carrying out operations combating the wide range of problems related to computers crimes in order that these efforts will be successful. It is also necessary to develop partnerships between the CIS and all other interested parties.

To reiterate, only by cooperation among nations will it be possible to stop the growth of Internet crime.

Date: December 25, 2007
Author: Vladimir Golubev

Asia Broadband and Internet Market Reports 2007

2007 Asia Broadband and Internet Market by Bharat Book Bureau contains over 460 pages of research and analysis on the Broadband and Internet markets in Asia. Consisting of 4 volumes this research covers 35 Asian countries, grouped by geographic regions (Central, North, South and South East) and includes -
· Internet infrastructure and development;
· Internet policies, models and concepts;
· Internet access - DSL, Cable, Wireless;
· Internet and broadband statistics;
· Internet censorship;
· Internet forecasts in selected countries;
· Internet Infrastructure and Developments;
· National Policies, Government Policies, Regulatory Regimes;
· Internet VPNs and VoIP;
· Network Operators, and ISPs.
· Network Players;
· xDSL, Cable Modem, FttH, Satellite;
· Wireless Broadband, WiMAX.

Executive Summary

2007 Asia Broadband and Internet Vertical Market
The 2007 Asia Broadband and Internet Market reports cover 35 countries in the Asia region. It takes an overall look at the various telecoms markets, together with a particular look at the Internet market segments.

Central Asia
While the countries of Central Asia have struggled with poor telecom infrastructure and underdeveloped regulatory, one segment of the market that has been most adversely affected has been the Internet. With none of these countries having Internet user penetrations higher than 10% at the end of 2006, the race is now on in each of the markets to build increased capacity to access the Internet. Turkmenistan and Tajikistan with Internet user penetrations of less than 1% by end-2006 are the lowest ranked by this measure and certainly have a huge task ahead of them. Right across the sub-region, Internet access has been predominantly provided as a dial-up service. The first signs of higher speed, broadband access services are evident in a number of the markets, but the total broadband subscriber base remains very tiny for the time being and therefore constitutes only a small proportion of the total Internet subscriber base in each country.
The rate of expansion of Internet services will no doubt increase on the back of the wider push to improve the overall telecoms capacity and infrastructure in each market. Although the pace is variable across the markets, there is certainly a consistent commitment to developing the national networks. Of course, it is not simply a matter of increased investment in infrastructure. There also needs to be a commitment with regard to regulatory reform. Interestingly, the Internet market has experienced some distinct challenges in Central Asia in this regard, as some of the governments have seen online access as a specific threat to national security and good order of their respective countries. The two lowly penetrated Internet markets, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan, have both been subjected to tight government restrictions and limitations on access, no doubt helping stunt the growth of online activity in both these countries. But they are not the only markets in Central Asia with laws aimed at Internet censorship. Kazakhstan and Georgia, for example, both have restrictive regulations in place that can be invoked as and when the government sees fit.

North Asia
In the rush to go online, North Asia is being led by a group of the most highly penetrated Internet markets in the world. With Asia the world’s leading regional Internet market in terms of subscribers, with the region North Asia is the outstanding driving Internet force. Not surprisingly, Internet growth in Asia continues to be dominated by the developed economies of North Asia - Japan, Hong Kong, South Korea and Taiwan. This group has been joined by China, based on its sheer weight of numbers; it was claiming 137 million Internet users by end-2006, a penetration in excess of 10%. South Korea is the top ranked North Asia market in terms of user penetration with 71%; at the other end of the spectrum is Mongolia with 10% and just behind China in user penetration.
A focus on high-speed broadband Internet access in its various forms is also a feature of North Asia’s Internet growth. Again, following the example set by market leader South Korea, the emphasis has been on delivering faster broadband speeds to the customers.
In terms of broadband access, Asia is one region in the world where Fibre-to-the-Home (FttH) has started to emerge as a serious broadband platform. The technology has taken off in a big way in Japan. There were already 10 million FttH subscribers in Japan by mid-2007. Not unexpectedly, the movement towards fibre has been occurring in Asia’s more developed markets, where positive government intervention has been playing an important role.

South Asia
Generally speaking, the penetration of Internet across South Asia remains low. Broadband access is almost non-existent across much of the sub-region and there are no signs of an early major upturn. The more significant impact of Internet in South Asia is to be found in India and Pakistan, where Internet usage is creeping towards 10% penetration. But for most of the other markets going online has been a struggle. One interesting exception has been the Maldives; with its small population combined with a healthy tourist industry, Internet usage has been relatively substantial.

South East Asia
Of Asia’s estimated 450 million Internet users in early 2007, only about 65 million were to be found in South East Asia. In other words, South East Asia had around 14% of the Internet user population of the region at the time. Despite highly penetrated Internet markets to be found in Singapore, Brunei and Malaysia, South East Asian economies are more generally in the developing phase when it comes to Internet, with user penetrations typically at the lower end of the scale. At the lowest level we find Laos, Cambodia and Myanmar, all with user penetrations of less than 1%.
In terms of broadband access, only Singapore rates as a highly penetrated market (65% of households by early 2007). Despite a flurry of activity in markets like Malaysia and Thailand, South Asia continues to lag well behind the more developed markets of the region in the application and penetration of broadband Internet access.

Source: Bharat Book Bureau

Kazakhstan Security Agency Says 125 Charged in 2007 with Secret Divulging

Kazakhstan's National Security Committee said yesterday that 125 officials had been charged in the country in 2007 with divulging official secrets but that the state had improved its secret protection system, news agency Interfax reports.

National Security Committee spokesman Kenzhebulat Beknazarov, who cited the figure at a news conference in Astana, said official secrets were under securer protection today. "Modern information security technologies have been introduced, and measures to ensure the information security of the 'electronic government' have been implemented," Beknazarov said.

A facility has been set up where government agencies have their information security tested via simulated Internet attacks, and dozens of cipher keys have been developed in a bid to protect government communications networks, Interfax is quoting the spokesman. Eleven cities have been supplied with more efficient government communications equipment. More than 300 units to which access is limited have been inspected and potential channels of information leaks have been closed, Beknazarov said.

"Work has been launched to build a national system for the prevention of cyber crime," the spokesman said. In 2007, "16 attempts at the illegal sale of specialized technical equipment have been cut short, and more than 180 products of this kind have been seized," he said.

Central Asia Telecoms Market Reports 2007

2007 Central Asia Telecoms Market Reports by Bharat Book Bureau, contains over 160 pages of research on Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Taijikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan. Consisting of 3 volumes the topics covered include: -

. National and International Infrastructure Issues;
. Fixed-line forecasts in selected countries;
. Telecom Investment and Revenue Statistics;
. Regulatory issues and government policies regarding infrastructure;
. Fixed-Line, VSAT, Wireless Local Loop Services;
· Brief overviews on all of the major telecommunications carriers and service providers in the region
. Internet access - DSL, Cable, Wireless
. Internet Infrastructure and Developments
. Internet and broadband statistics;
. Internet censorship;
. Internet forecasts in selected countries;
· Internet Infrastructure and Developments
· Network Operators and ISPs
· Internet Market, VPNs and VoIP
· Vision for a National Policy, Government Policies
· Network Operators, Wholesalers and Retailers, Utilities Projects
· xDSL, HFC, MDS, Satellite, Cable Modems, Cable Telephony
· Wireless Broadband
· Trends, Analysis, Players, Revenues, Subscribers, Prepaid
· Spectrum Auctions, Developments, Govt. Policies
· Infrastructure, GSM, CDMA, 3G
. Mobile Data Services - SMS, MMS, GPRS, EDGE, CDMA;
. Mobile Forecasts in Selected Countries;
. Mobile Operators;
. Mobile Satellite Services;
. Mobile Spectrum Licensing;
. Mobile Statistics and Trends - Subscribers, Operators, Revenues;
. Mobile Technologies - GSM, CDMA, 3G.

Executive Summary

This market report covers eight countries in the Central Asia sub-region. It takes an overall look at the various telecoms markets, together with a particular look at the telecom statistics which describe the market in each of the following countries: Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan.

The nations of Central Asia, following the winning of independence following the collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s, were characteristically suffering from poor and inadequate infrastructure. Their respective telecom networks were in particularly bad condition at the time, in some cases on the verge of total collapse. The process of building and rebuilding crumbling telecom infrastructures has been a long and difficult one. Fixed-line penetration remains low across the sub-region, with no country having more than 20% fixed teledensity. More critically, a large proportion of these networks are yet to be fully converted to or replaced by digital equipment. Of course, the ability to address the need for infrastructure is closely linked to the economic prosperity of a country; whilst none of these countries is classed as a Least Developed Country, the majority have had major economic challenges to address.
The state of the fixed-line networks made it inevitable that mobile services would be seen by the governments and operators alike as the way to provide much needed communications and essentially offer a quick solution to ‘filling the gap’. It still took time for the momentum to develop, but over the last few years it has finally started to happen. Right across the sub-region, mobile markets have been booming; Kazakhstan, the most highly penetrated mobile market in Central Asia (49%), has been through a major growth surge and was continuing to grow at more than 30% per annum coming into 2007. At the other end of the scale is the lowly penetrated Tajikistan (5%), whose subscriber numbers have jumped sharply, growing by almost 150% in 2006.
One of the major challenges for these markets has been to introduce the much-needed regulatory reforms and to generally open the respective markets up to competition. Considerable progress has been made right across the sub-region on the regulatory reform front, although inevitably some countries are dong better than others. Kyrgyzstan, for example, was one the fastest of the CIS to liberalise its economy and was the first Central Asian Republic to join the WTO in 1998. Turkmenistan, while steadily rebuilding its economy, has prompted questions to be raised about governance matters. Tajikistan, which has also finally made some economic progress, suffers from the illegal drug trade and the resulting corruption within government.

Armenia
Armenia’s telecom sector has started to grow. There are over 600,000 fixed-line subscribers and more than 800,000 mobile subscribers for a population of almost 4 million people. The level of investment in infrastructure and new services has begun to increase. There are, however, major structural issues to be addressed in the sector. Amid growing dissatisfaction over the performance of the telecoms network, in November 2004 the government reached a compromise agreement with ArmenTel, the country’s national telecom provider, to end its exclusive rights to provide mobile, satellite, and mobile radio communications services in exchange for various other concessions, including the stipulation that only one alternative mobile operator would be allowed to operate in Armenia until 2009. ArmenTel was also allowed to retain sole rights to Internet telephony and the use of fibre optic cables. Previously, ArmenTel had been granted exclusive rights to the provision of all telecommunications services in Armenia until 2013 (apart from data services).

Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan is continuing to make steady progress in developing its telecom sector, but still faces numerous problems. Poor quality infrastructure has been a major ongoing problem. Only around half the telephone lines in the country are digital. The monopoly held by Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Communications, among other things, results in the high cost of satellite connections. As well as being a commercial operator through its role in AzTelecom, the ministry is both policy-maker and regulator for the telecoms sector in Azerbaijan. The country’s significant dependence on international funding has also made it difficult for any long-range planning in the development of the sector.
The good news: by 2006, GDP growth was running at an estimated 30%. A rapid increase in capital investment has been largely responsible for the country’s recent impressive growth record. Much of the capital investment has been from foreign sources and mainly directed towards major oil and gas field developments. Government-owned AzTelecom remains Azerbaijan’s main telecommunications service provider and operates under the umbrella of the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (MCIT). A second operator, AzEuroTel, won a licence to provide international communication services in 1999. There are also four joint ventures offering telephone services, two mobile operators, and a number of ISPs operating in Azerbaijan. All these ventures have been established under the ministry.

Georgia
Although steadily improving, Georgia’s telecommunications infrastructure remains outmoded and inadequate as a result of gradual under-investment over decades. However, there has been an upward trend in the country’s telecom market over the past few years, with rising revenues and increased investment in infrastructure. Mobile communication systems have become increasingly important because the fixed-line facilities provided in many places (particularly in rural and remote areas) are outdated and a mobile phone represents the only effective means of communication.
In an interesting move, in April 2006, the Georgian National Communications Commission awarded a 3G mobile licence to Argotex, a local textiles company. Positive developments in Georgia that will help the expansion of its telecom infrastructure include the establishment of an independent regulator for the telecom sector and the ongoing privatisation of the two largest fixed-line operators, Sakartvelos Telekomi and Sakartvelos Elektrokavshiri. Competition has become the norm for all segments of the telecom market, including fixed-line services.

Kazakhstan
Kazakhstan’s telecoms market is growing on a wide front. The dynamic nature of the market will ensure the rapid introduction of new infrastructure and the upgrade of old equipment (Just over 70% of the national network was digital in 2006). Legislation adopted in 2004 started the liberalisation of the telecom sector and ended Kazakhtelecom’s monopoly. By April 2005, four companies had been licensed to provide international and long-distance services in competition with Kazakhtelecom and by the end of the year, over 1,000 licences had been issued for the provision of a range of telecom services.
Rapid development in the country’s mobile market has been a feature of the sector. Although Internet penetration remains low for the moment, there is increasing interest in going online. The scene is set for further growth in the telecoms sector. Economic activity had remained very strong in Kazakhstan, with 2006 marking the seventh consecutive year of real GDP growth in excess of 8%. With a GDP of more than US$70 billion in 2006 and a GDP per capita approaching US$5,000 (compared with Russia’s GDP per capita of US$6,800), it is not surprising to find significant growth in the country’s telecom sector. National operator, Kazakhtelecom has launched a program to modernise the country’s telecommunications system. The plan includes modernising the company’s rural telecommunications network using digital telephone exchanges. The company has also been installing satellite facilities in Kazakhstan’s rural and remote areas.

Kyrgyzstan
Kyrgyzstan, despite being one of the least developed countries in the region, has progressed further and faster than other CIS to liberalise its economy; it was in fact the first Central Asian Republic to join the WTO. While much has been done to modernise Kyrgyzstan’s telecom network, geographical conditions, a high incidence of poverty and a still developing legal and regulatory framework remain key obstacles to expanding telecom operations. The good news is that the telecom market has been opened to both foreign and domestic investors and an independent regulator has been established to oversee the sector. Full liberalisation of the market was set for end-2006. As a consequence of this, the sector has been attracting strong foreign investment interest as well as considerable economic and technical assistance of various types. Since the start of market reforms in 1991, the national operator Kyrgyztelecom has been expanding and upgrading its outdated and poorly distributed network.
In January 2006, the government approved a decision to put 77.8% of Kyrgyztelecom up for sale. The country’s second GSM network was also launched in April 2006. Much has been done in recent years to modernise the Kyrgyzstan’s telecom network. Telecommunication projects worth more than US$50 million have been implemented to develop the national infrastructure and upgrade systems. These projects have been financed with the help of US$27 million in loans from the World Bank and the EBRD. The national infrastructure program included creating a digital network, digital radio-relay stations and a fibre optic links.

Tajikistan
Of all the countries that emerged from the former Soviet Union, Tajikistan arguably had the least developed telecommunications network. With a network that was near total collapse at the time, the government has started the daunting task of bringing it up to modern standards. The network is tiny, providing service to a subscriber base that represents a fixed-line teledensity of less than 5% coming into 2007, and, significant proportion of the Tajikistan network has not yet been converted to digital. A gradual process of liberalisation is under way and over the last decade a significant number of private operators have been allowed to enter the telecom market, notably in the mobile and Internet sectors. Privatisation of state-owned fixed-line operator, Tajiktelecom was expected to be achieved by end-2007. The mobile sector experienced a major growth surge in 2006, the subscriber base jumping by almost 80%. Despite the healthy growth in the mobile sector, combined fixed-line and mobile teledensity was estimated at less than 15% in early 2007.

Turkmenistan
Turkmenistan is yet another of the nations that emerged from the former Soviet Union with an underdeveloped telecommunications sector. In fact, it is claimed that telecommunications services in Turkmenistan were the least developed of all the CIS countries. Poor growth in telecoms services, the slow progress in the development of the private sector and continuing state control over most economic activities have not been helpful in attempts to grow the country’s telecommunications market. Combined fixed-line and mobile teledensity was estimated at close to 13% by end-2006. Fixed-line growth has been virtually stagnant for almost a decade.

Uzbekistan
Uzbekistan has been struggling to bring its telecom system up to the standard found in developed countries. Although steadily improving, some of the telecommunications infrastructure remains outmoded and inadequate. With slightly less than 2 million fixed line telephone services at the end of 2006 for a population of almost 27 million, the national network still has 35% of equipment yet to be replaced or converted to digital. Certainly, however, the situation has been steadily improving, due largely to the government’s decision to give priority to the telecom sector. In 1996, in what was a significant move, the government started inviting foreign telecom companies to invest in Uzbekistan in their own right. This was followed by the creation in 2000 of Uzbektelecom, a holding company charged with operating the national telecommunications network.

There has been an upward trend in the country’s telecom market over recent years, with rising revenues and increased investment in infrastructure. In January 2007, the country’s telecom regulator reported that investment in the telecommunications sector in Uzbekistan had risen 69% year on year to UZS179.6 billion (US$145 million) in 2006. It was also reported that foreign investment in the Uzbek telecom sector rose 39% year on year to US$133 million; telecom operators’ revenues rose 55.6% year on year in 2006 to UZS622.6 billion (US$500 million). The next step in the government’s strategic program is to privatise the incumbent operator Uzbektelecom and to open the market to competition consistent with the country’s aim to join the WTO.

Source: Bharat Book Research

Fiber-Optic Cable Line through Black Sea-Caucasus-Central Asia

Baku. A project of high-speed fiber-optic cable line to run from the Black Sea basin to Central Asia through the Caucasus is being prepared on Azerbaijan’s initiative.

Ali Abbasov, the communication minister of Azerbaijan, said that an international conference will be arranged in Baku this March or April for this project debates.

“The meeting will cover opportunities of creation of an operating consortium and project cost. Azerbaijan comes forward a central country in the project. The cable line project will allow removal of information vacuum of the countries of Black Sea basin, Caucasus and Asia,” Abbasov said.

The project developed from the idea of laying a Trans-Caspian segment of TAE Project, interest to which was displayed by Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Turkey.

Source: Fineko/abc.az

International Telecoms Eye Central Asian Mobile Market

International telecoms are eager to expand their presence in Central Asia, their hopes buoyed by low, but growing penetration rates and the absence of a quality fixed line infrastructure. Researchers, meanwhile, are finding that mobile phones are preferred over the Internet as a means for receiving information.

Global telecommunications companies are spurred on in Central Asia by the success of mobile phone penetration in Russia, where the latest figures indicate there are now 106 mobile phones for every 100 citizens. Telecoms research analysts now describe Central Asia as an "obvious opportunity."

An annual review by OFCOM, the British regulatory body, characterized China and Russia as powerhouses in the global telecoms sector, both in terms of money and also technological advances.

Some analysts believe Central Asia is poised to follow the Russian model of mobile phone development. "The mobile market in Central Asia is getting quite competitive, while the fixed market is still bugged by slow liberalization and the lack of modern infrastructure," said Bakhyt Weeks, an analyst with the telecoms advisory company, Pyramid Research.

"The situation in the fixed markets [in Central Asia] is quite similar to that in Russia, if not worse," Weeks continued. "The incumbents still control all of the local telephone markets; some competition exists in the long-distance and international [spheres]. The development of broadband is held back by the low fixed-line penetration and low digitalization. Additionally, the lack of competition due to the absence of the local loop unbundling (LLU), keeps the prices high, preventing better adoption."

This environment creates ample opportunity for mobile providers to expand their positions in Central Asia. Already, greater competition and cheaper services has resulted in an "explosion in mobile phone usage" said Weeks.

"Kazakhstan’s mobile penetration grew from around 42 percent to almost 69 percent in 2007. Uzbekistan’s penetration doubled from 10 percent to 20 percent in 2007. … This trend is set to continue in all of the markets. The entrance of MTS, Vimpelcom, and TeliaSonera in some of the markets will significantly boost competition, lower prices, and widen the range of services," she said.

Beth Kolko, a professor at the University of Washington’s Department of Technical Communication, is conducting a three-year survey of information and communication technologies in Central Asia. She said demand for mobile services had risen swiftly since they were introduced in the late 1990s.

"The growth throughout the region has been phenomenal both in terms of the number of subscribers and the number of providers," she said. "The mobile phone takes root pretty rapidly because of infrastructure issues. Where landlines are difficult to acquire or expensive, mobile phones find a very friendly audience. You can see that throughout Africa and Asia … and Central Asia is no different."

Kolko’s preliminary research in Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan reveals distinctive usage patterns. The Internet remains too costly for most, and as a result, the mobile phone has taken on a unique role as information tool, she said. "What we see in usage is primarily voice and SMS. There’s not much mobile web, a little in Kazakhstan, but generally - even though the services are available in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan and the people I’ve interviewed know it’s available - it’s just too expensive, said Kolko.

The growth in Internet users appears to be leveling off, while the number of mobile phone subscribers continues to increase, according to Kolko’s early data. A possible explanation for the flat Internet numbers is connected with governmental desires to control the flow of information and maintain firm grip over the political spheres in the respective countries.

A recent survey issued by the political rights group Freedom House found Central Asian states to be among the world’s more repressive regimes. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive]. Leaders in many Central Asia states, most notably in Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan, have managed to establish a large measure of control over the Internet, mainly through the tight management of service providers. Officials have not managed to impose the same level of control over mobile phones. Explanations for the continued growth of mobile phone usage include the possibility that they are a lucrative source of income for ruling elites; that officials simply have not gotten around to focusing on the mobile market; or perhaps authorities have found the market is so large that new methods of control must be developed in order to harness the flow of information.

Kolko suggests another major factor at work is the relative user-friendliness of mobile phones over the Internet for the peoples of Central Asia. "Oftentimes people will group information and communication technologies into one bucket, but we are seeing a divergence of attitudes towards the Internet and towards mobile phones," Kolko said. "People are seeing mobile phones as much easier to use. They’ll describe the language barrier as similar for both the Internet and mobile phones, but they still perceive the mobile as easier to use."

People in Central Asia are using mobile phones not just for conversations, but to obtain information, Kolko found. "There are some very sophisticated information resources available in certain parts of Central Asia, and from certain providers where subscribers can access directory services et cetera via text messaging. These are things that people use with some frequency."

Kolko added Central Asia’s track record could only inspire confidence in the sector. "They don’t have the 3G bandwidth that you see in other countries, but if you look at the map of coverage across the countries, you can see that huge parts of the region are in fact served by mobiles in early 2008. That wasn’t the case in 2003 or 2004, but it is now."

Author: Deirdre Tynan, freelance journalist who specializes in Central Asian affairs.

Posted January 18, 2008 © http://www.eurasianet.org

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Kazakhstan Participates in the Internet Telephony Conference & Expo



This winter Kazakhstan will participate in the Internet Telephony Conference & Expo which will be held at the Miami Beach Convention
Center in Miami, Florida in January 23-25.

Last year (2007) just about a week before ITEXPO (Internet Telephony Expo) there were 64 countries represented. This year, also just 1 week away from Internet Telephony Expo there are 74 countries represented, which is about a 15.6% increase.

What is INTERNET TELEPHONY Conference & EXPO?

ITEXPO is the event with an educational program that teaches enterprises, SMBs, and Government Agencies how to select and deploy IP-based voice, video, fax, and unified communications. It's where service providers learn how to profitably roll out services their subscribers are clamoring for. The vibrant Exhibit Hall features solutions for enterprises, SMBs, government and service providers. ITEXPO is where buyers, sellers, resellers, and manufacturers meet to forge relationships and close deals.

Full list of countries-participants 2008:
Argentina Australia Bahamas Belgium Belize Bolivia Bosnia-Herzegovina Brazil Burundi Cameroon Canada Chile China Peoples Rep Colombia Costa Rica Cyprus Czech Republic Denmark Dominican Republic Dubai Ecuador Egypt (Arab Rep of) El Salvador Finland France Germany Ghana Guadeloupe Guatemala Honduras Hungary India Iran Israel Italy Ivory Coast Jamaica Japan Kazakhstan Liberia Malaysia Mexico Morocco Nepal Netherlands Nicaragua Nigeria Norway Pakistan Panama Peru Philippines Qatar Romania Russian Federation Rwanda Saudi Arabia Sierra Leone Singapore Slovenia Spain Sri Lanka St Kitts-Nevis Sweden Switzerland Uganda Ukraine United Arab Emirates United Kingdom Uruguay USA Venezuela Yugoslavia Zimbabwe

As you see Kazakhstan is the first and only Central Asian country represented at the Conference & Expo.

Sunday, January 13, 2008

Kazakh Government Will Insist on Faster Internet

State Agency for Informatization and Communications plans to impose new requirements on the Kazakhstani Internet Service Providers. The requirements refer to the minimal speed for a broadband connection - not less than 256 Kbps. This condition, according to the agency, corresponds to the basic standards of the International Telecommunication Union.

“We will insist that the increased speed should not lead to the increased price”, the state agency underscored.

Will the domestic providers do so — reduce the price two times and lose additional income they receive now from the use of diverse tariff bars, which are formed on the basis of different speed of access? If the government is going to be persistent enough, then the ISPs will have to make a concession. But, in order to compensate their losses, they most likely will abandon unlimited tariff plans.

Source: neweurasia.net

Internet Expansion Is Among Turkmenistan Government Priorities for 2008

Turkmen President Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov summed up the results of the year 2007 and set new tasks for the government at the Cabinet of Ministers meeting on December 27.

"We are holding this meeting ahead of the New Year holiday, and we have every reason to celebrate it in a cheerful mood because we have done a lot indeed. There is much more work to do in the coming year of 2008. That is why we have to put it in our plan of work starting today," the head of state said.

The introduction of the principles of market economy in Turkmenistan, development of new oil and gas fields, adjusting the national legislature to the standards of the international law, expansion of the construction industry basis, creation of a wide network of transport communications, increasing exports of Turkmen products, intensification of the textile industry development and expansion of Internet network were named among the priority tasks.

According to Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov, the further direction of social-economic reforms in Turkmensitan will be discussed at a big forum which is to take place during Galla Baryamy - grain holiday marked annually on the third Sunday of July.

Source: turkmenistan.ru

Best Kazakhstan Blog Award by Medianet


The Almaty-based International Center for Journalism MediaNet together with the Soros Foundation in Kazakhstan has announced the results of best weblog contest. The competition brought together 30 applications from bloggers running their websites both in Kazakh and in Russian, both personally and in groups.

Results:

1. Blog by Adil Nurmakov ("Adam Kesher"), Almaty
http://adam-kesher.livejournal.com/

Judges' comments: "lively, always relevant and probably the most popular and interesting among Kazakhstan blogs".

Prize: 1000USD

2. Blog by Marat Shibutov, Almaty
http://megakhuimyak.livejournal.com/

Comments: "one of the pithiest blogs".

and Kazakh-language version of group blog Neweurasia
http://kz.kazakhstan.neweurasia.net/

Comments: "one of the most high-quality blogs in state language containing a lot of valuable and relevant information".

Prize: 300USD

3. Blog by Bakytnur Baitelula, South Korean university
http://bakytnur.wordpress.com/ (Science, techology, art and culture)

and Vitaly Mantrov, Shymkent http://mantrovkz.livejournal.com/
(Politics, economy, social life)


Judges notes about both blogs: "variety of topics", "relevancy" and "interesting style"

Prize: 200USD

Different researches mention that there are about 4000-7000 Kazakhstan blogs.


Original source in Russian language: Medianet.kz

Number of Internet Users in Turkmenistan to Grow

ASHGABAT (turkmenistan.ru). A project on expanding the capacity of Internet network has started in Turkmenistan.

It is expected that the first phase of the project will be finished before December 2008. The winner of the international tender, Russian TechnoServ A/C company, will carry out all works related to the project. The total cost of the contract is US $1,6 million.


As a result of the project, the number of dial-up internet users in Turkmenistan will grow to 20 thousand and the number of broadband internet users to 1,1 thousand. 14 new servers in Ashgabat and 10 servers in the provinces of Turkmenistan will provide internet access.

As the Turkmenistan.ru's correspondent has learnt from the ministry of communication of Turkmenistan, the project also envisages enhancing the internet speed to 150 megabit a second. The project will be implemented by a winner of an international tender which is to be announced this month.

Saturday, January 12, 2008

KODE5 Gaming Competition Comes to Uzbekistan

Uzbekistan becomes the first Central Asian country to participate in KODE5 International Gaming Competition. Here is the news article from the official web-site:

(Tashkent, UZBEKISTAN) – January 8th, 2007 – The Global Gaming Revolution continues to expand as gamers around the world rise up one by one. Today, another nation joins our cause to spread the message of competitive gaming. KODE5, in association with GLOBUS Internet Club, is pleased to launch KODE5 Uzbekistan. From the largest Internet Café in the nation, Counter-Strike 1.6 and Warcraft III: Frozen Throne gamers will have the opportunity to compete for the right to represent Uzbekistan at the KODE5 Global Finals. With Global Supporters Cooler Master, GIGABYTE, and Corsair Memory, the KODE5 Global Gaming Revolution brings competitive gaming to the forefront with events in 16 countries across the globe.

Details for the KODE5 Uzbekistan event are as follows:

KODE5 Uzbekistan Regional Qualifier

DATES: January 27th ~ 28th, 2008

VENUE: GLOBUS Internet Club

LOCATION: Tashkent, Uzbekistan

GAMES: Counter-Strike 1.6, Warcraft III: TFT

LINK: http://www.esport.uz

For Uzbekistan’s first KODE5 event, GLOBUS is holding the qualifiers at their premier Internet café. Located in the heart of Tashkent, the capital city, GLOBUS Internet Club is the largest of its kind, with convenient access to subway, bus stations, hotels, shops and more. A spectator zone with both Russian and English commentary will be available for e-sports fans to witness the action.

To register for this exciting event, gamers have to first sign up for a free account on KODE5.com, and then register for KODE5 Uzbekistan at http://www.esport.uz or in person at the GLOBUS Internet Club.

"We are thrilled to be working with KODE5 this year
," noted Shirkhodjaev "Greed_uz" Sergey, GLOBUS Project Manager. "The gaming community in Uzbekistan is growing quickly, and it's great to have the support of global tournaments like KODE5 to help bring Uzbekistan gaming to the world stage. We are excited to join the revolution!"



▲ GLOBUS Internet Club, Tashkent, Uzbekistan


▲ Tournament action will happen In the Game Zone


KODE5 continues to pick up momentum with the launch of KODE5 Uzbekistan,” says Lester Lau, KODE5 Revolutionary-in-Command. “We are happy to be working with GLOBUS to bring an international-scale competitive gaming event to Uzbekistan and further promote competitive gaming in this area of the world.

To celebrate the launch of KODE5 in Uzbekistan, Global Supporters Cooler Master, GIGABYTE, and Corsair Memory will be there to demonstrate their latest selection of killer gaming gear.

Glad to see Uzbekistan join the global gaming community with KODE5,” commented Tony Liao, Director of Marketing at GIGABYTE. “We are proud to be able to help bring this year's KODE5 Revolution to Uzbekistan, and wish everyone here has the best gaming experience.

For details on how to register for this exciting event, check out KODE5’s official website: www.kode5.com.






Source: kode5.com

Uzbekistan is in Top 75 Countries in Facebook


Uzbekistan is the only Central Asian country in Top 75 countries using Facebook and the number of Uzbek Facebook users is growing.

Population: 27 372 000 (source: Wikipedia)
Facebook users 08/12/2007: 1 766 (rank 71)
Facebook users 08/01/2008: 2 069 (rank 70)
Month difference: 17,16%
% of the population: 0,006%

More data: SEO & Web Marketing News. Canadian Blog

Internet "Black Holes" 2007 by Reporters Without Borders


"Reporters Without Borders" published report about 15 countries with limited freedom of expression on the Internet on their point of view:
1. Belarus
2. Burma
3. China
4. Cuba
5. Iran
6. Libya
7. Maldives
8. Nepal
9. North Korea
10. Saudi Arabia
11. Syria
12. Tunisia
13. Turkmenistan
14. Uzbekistan
15. Vietnam

Here is the detailed description on Central Asian countries from the report:

Turkmenistan

With less than 1 per cent of the population online, this is one of the world’s least connected countries. President Separmurad Nyazov is a central Asian Kim Jong-Il, wielding total control over the media. Not only is the Turkmen Internet censored, it is also forbidden territory for the vast majority of the population.

Uzbekistan

Official censorship seems to have become even tougher since the bloody crackdown on the pro-democracy protests in Andidjan in May 2005. The iron-fisted government led by President Islam Karimov blocks access to most independent websites dealing with Uzbekistan, which are usually hosted on servers in Russia, and to NGO websites that criticise its human rights violations.

Connect Tajikistan Project Overview

The Global Connections and Exchange Program for Central Asia has established 26 Internet Learning Centers (ILCs) in secondary schools across Tajikistan. The program’s main goal is to increase global dialogue and educational opportunities by installing modern computer equipment with Internet access in schools, as well as developing training and learning projects for teachers and students. Connect Tajikistan is funded by the Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs of the US Department of State.
The Global Connections and Exchange Program for Tajikistan activities include:

  • training educators on using computers and the Internet in classroom teaching

  • partnering with US schools on student-centered civic education projects and teacher exchanges

  • providing public access and programs for community members and disadvantaged groups

  • developing sustainable practices for schools and communities

OSCE Report: Governing the Internet in Kazakhstan

Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) published a report called "Governing the Internet - Freedom and Regulation in the OSCE Region".

Link: Download Governing the Internet Report

On pages 119-131 it has article by Rachid Nougmanov called "Internet Governance in Kazakhstan" which criticizes the governance and underlines the expensiveness of the Internet connection comparing to the salaries.

Link to article about it on Ars Technica website:
Internet Prices in Kazakhstan based on OSCE Report

Link to article about it on Ars Technica website:
Kazakhstan here we come

Best Governmental Websites in Kyrgyzstan 2007

UNDP Democratic Governance Program has named the winners of the Best Website contest held among ministries and agencies, the press service of the UNDP reported.

14 ministries and agencies have participated in the contest. The jury was composed by representatives of state bodies, civil society and business sector. They evaluated weak and strong points of the websites, including their content, usefulness and usability.

The website of the Ministry of Justice www.minjust.kg (currently unavailable) awarded the first place. The website is easy-to-use and provides free access to the regulatory acts of Kyrgyzstan. The Ministry received $1000.

The website of the Ministry of Finance www.minfin.kg was honored with the second place and $700.

The third place was shared by the websites of the State Tax Committee www.sti.gov.kg and State Agency on Vocational Education www.kesip.in.kg. Both agencies received $400.

The awards will be used to purchase digital and computer equipment (photo cameras, scanners, voice recorders, etc.) to meet the winners needs.

Source: 24.kg